AU Ideas: 60 Alternate Universe Prompts for Fanfic, and How to Keep Characters In Character

An AU (alternate universe) takes characters you already know and puts them somewhere they were never meant to be: a coffee shop, a royal court, a space station, a world where they never met. The setting is the easy part. The hard part is the first scene, when you have to decide what these people would actually do here.

This list has 60 AU ideas grouped by setting. Each one comes with a question, because a setting alone is a costume change; the question is what turns it into a story. After the list there is a short check for keeping characters in character, and a worked example.

What makes an AU work

A good AU changes the world and keeps the person. Readers come back to an AU because they want to see these characters react to new pressure. If the characters turn into generic baristas or generic knights, the AU has lost the reason anyone clicked on it.

Before you pick a setting, write down four things about each character:

  1. What they want most. Not their job in canon. The thing underneath it.
  2. What they are afraid of. The fear usually survives any setting change.
  3. How they talk. Sentence length, what they joke about, what they never say out loud.
  4. How they treat the other person. For a pairing, this is the dynamic readers came for.

Then ask of every AU idea below: what in this world presses on those four things? A coffee shop AU works when the shop itself pushes on what the character wants or fears. If nothing presses, you have a nice backdrop and no plot.

Modern and everyday AUs

  1. Coffee shop AU. One works the counter, one is the regular. What does the regular order that tells the barista more than they meant to?
  2. Bookstore AU. Who keeps reshelving the same book in the wrong section, and why?
  3. Roommates AU. What household rule does one of them break on purpose?
  4. Neighbors AU. The walls are thin. What does one of them overhear every night?
  5. College AU. Same class, different reasons for taking it. Who is failing, and who notices?
  6. Office AU. They report to the same manager and want the same promotion.
  7. Hospital AU. Nurse and long-stay patient, or two doctors on the same night shift. Who is hiding exhaustion?
  8. Small-town AU. One left years ago and has just come back. Who never left?
  9. Road trip AU. Two people, one car, a destination only one of them wants to reach.
  10. Wedding AU. They are both in the wedding party of someone else. Who is not okay with this wedding?

Job swap AUs

  1. Firefighter AU. Who runs toward the fire, and who is quietly counting the exits?
  2. Teacher AU. Two teachers at a failing school. What are they each willing to bend the rules for?
  3. Florist and tattoo artist AU. Shops next door. Each keeps sending customers to the other.
  4. Lighthouse keeper AU. One keeper, one visitor who keeps finding reasons to stay one more night.
  5. Chef AU. A kitchen during the dinner rush, where every mistake is public.
  6. Musician AU. A band about to break up, or two rivals booked at the same venue.
  7. Detective AU. One investigates, one is a witness who is lying about a small thing.
  8. Ghostwriter AU. One writes the other's memoir and learns more than they should.

Fantasy AUs

  1. Royalty AU. A prince and a guard, or two heirs promised to each other. What does the crown cost each of them?
  2. Knight AU. A sworn knight and the person they swore to protect. What happens when protecting them means disobeying them?
  3. Witch AU. One runs an apothecary, one keeps coming in for a cure they won't name.
  4. Dragon rider AU. The dragon chose the wrong rider, or so everyone says.
  5. Fae AU. Never say thank you, never give your name. Who slips first?
  6. Mermaid / selkie AU. One belongs to the sea. What would they give up to stay on land?
  7. Cursed AU. One is cursed, the other is the only one who knows how it breaks.
  8. Monster hunter AU. The hunter is assigned to track the other. The trail leads somewhere personal.
  9. Necromancer AU. One can bring back the dead and refuses to. Who are they being asked to bring back?
  10. Guardian spirit AU. One is a household spirit tied to a house; the other just moved in.

Sci-fi AUs

  1. Space station AU. A small crew, one broken system, and someone who knows why it broke.
  2. Android AU. One is not human and is very good at pretending. Who figures it out first?
  3. Time loop AU. One of them is living the same day again. The other doesn't remember any of the previous ones.
  4. Cyberpunk AU. A courier and a hacker, and a delivery neither should have opened.
  5. Post-apocalypse AU. Two survivors with one map, disagreeing about where safety is.
  6. Generation ship AU. Born on a ship that won't arrive in their lifetime. What do they each believe about the destination?
  7. Clone AU. One wakes up and meets a copy of the other who remembers things differently.
  8. First contact AU. One is the translator. What do they leave out?

Historical AUs

  1. Regency AU. A season of balls and one marriage that has to happen by the end of it.
  2. Victorian AU. A gaslit city, a scandal, and a letter that should have been burned.
  3. Wild West AU. A sheriff and someone with a price on their head, in a town too small for both.
  4. Pirate AU. A captain and the navy officer chasing them, who keeps letting them get away.
  5. 1920s AU. A speakeasy, a jazz singer, and an undercover agent who likes the music too much.
  6. Wartime AU. A radio operator and someone on the other end of the signal they have never met.

Genre swap AUs

  1. Mafia AU. Two families, one alliance, two people who don't trust it.
  2. Heist AU. A crew of specialists. Who is planning to double-cross the others?
  3. Sports team AU. Captain and the transfer who wants their spot.
  4. Idol AU. A group whose public image is nothing like what happens backstage.
  5. Noir AU. Rain, a case that's too simple, and a client who knows more than they say.
  6. Horror AU. A house that changes at night, and one of them who isn't scared enough.
  7. Reality show AU. Strangers in a house with cameras. Who is playing a character?
  8. Fairy tale AU. Retell a fairy tale with the roles assigned against type. Who is the villain now?

Soulmate AUs

  1. Soulmark AU. The first words your soulmate will say to you are written on your skin. One of them has very ordinary words.
  2. Timer AU. A countdown to meeting your soulmate. One timer reads zero, and nobody is there.
  3. Red string AU. Only one of them can see the string.
  4. Color AU. The world is gray until you meet them. What is the first color one of them sees, and where?
  5. Shared pain AU. You feel your soulmate's injuries. One of them keeps getting hurt and won't explain.

Role swap and what-if AUs

  1. Role reversal AU. Swap their canon roles: the leader follows, the follower leads.
  2. Villain wins AU. The bad ending happened. How do they find each other after it?
  3. First meeting AU. They didn't meet when canon says they did. Where do they cross paths instead?
  4. Different choice AU. At one decision point in canon, one of them chose the other way.
  5. Age swap AU. The older one is younger now. What do they understand differently?

How to pick one

A long list makes picking harder, so narrow it from the scene backwards:

  • Start from the scene you want to write, not the setting. If you want a scene where one character finally admits they were scared, look for an AU that forces that admission (a cursed AU, a time loop, a hospital night shift).
  • Pick the AU that presses on the fear you wrote down. A character afraid of being left fits a small-town AU about the one who came back. A character afraid of losing control fits a heist or a knight AU.
  • Check that both characters have a reason to stay. In a pairing, an AU breaks down when only one of them has a reason to be in the room.

If you can name the first scene and the reason neither of them leaves, you have an AU.

A worked example

Here are two original characters: Odile, a nineteen-year-old apprentice lighthouse keeper, warm and chatty by day and quieter after dark, and Tamsin, a cartographer who maps the coast and hates being looked after.

Move them into a coffee shop AU:

Stays the sameChanges
OdileWants to keep a light on for people who are out late. Talks a lot until it gets dark.She runs the night shift at a 24-hour café by the harbor.
TamsinHates being looked after. Draws maps of everything.She is the regular who sketches the street map on napkins and never finishes her coffee.
Their dynamicOdile notices things; Tamsin pretends not to be noticed.Odile starts leaving a fresh cup without being asked.

First scene: it's 2 a.m., the café is empty, and Tamsin finds that Odile has kept every napkin map she ever left behind.

Nothing about the lighthouse survived the move. Everything about the two of them did, and that is what makes it an AU instead of a new story with borrowed names.

Turn an AU into headcanons

Once you have a setting, the next step is the small details: what each character orders, what they do on a slow night, what they would never admit. These are headcanons, and they are where an AU starts to feel lived-in.

The headcanon generator does this for you. Type a character's name (or two, for a pairing), choose AU / what if as the situation, and you get three headcanon ideas, each with why it fits the character and three scene prompts to start writing from. It works for canon characters and original characters, and you can try it with a free account.

Writing a pairing and need a name for them? The ship name generator blends two names into a ship name, no account needed.

If your AU keeps drifting from the source, keep canon and your own changes in separate places. The fanfic setting sheet has one layer for canon and one for your headcanons, and managing canon in fan work covers the method.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does AU mean in fanfic?
AU stands for *alternate universe*. It means the story places canon characters in a setting or situation different from the original work, such as a coffee shop, a fantasy kingdom or a world where a key event went differently.
What is the difference between an AU and canon divergence?
Canon divergence keeps the original world, changes one event, and follows what happens next. It is a kind of AU (AO3 tags it "Alternate Universe - Canon Divergence"), and number 59 on this list. When fans say "AU" on its own, they usually mean a new setting.
Is a crossover an AU?
Not usually. A crossover brings characters from two works together. An AU moves characters from one work into a new setting. A story can be both, for example two fandoms' characters meeting in a coffee shop AU.
How do I keep characters in character in an AU?
Keep what they want, what they fear, how they talk and how they treat each other. Change the world around those four things, and let the new setting put pressure on them.
Can I write AUs for original characters?
Yes. An OC AU is a good way to test whether you know a character well: if they still feel like themselves in a completely different world, you have found what is essential about them.