Fanfic Ideas: 6 Ways to Find Your Next Story, with 40 Prompts
Most fanfic ideas come from the same six places: a scene canon skipped, what happened after the ending, one moment that goes differently, a new setting, a side character's point of view, or a familiar trope applied to characters you love. If you are stuck, you rarely need a brand-new idea. You need to look in one of these places on purpose.
Each section below explains one source and gives prompts you can start from. At the end there is a short check for turning any idea into a first scene.
1. The missing scene
Canon skips time. Characters travel between episodes, recover off-page, and have conversations we only hear about later. A missing scene fills one of those gaps, and because it sits inside canon, readers already care about it.
Where to look: the line "a few days later," a time skip between seasons or arcs, an injury that heals between chapters, any conversation a character mentions but we never see.
Prompts:
- The night after the biggest fight in canon. Who can't sleep?
- The first meal the group shares after someone comes back.
- The walk home from a scene that ended on a cliffhanger.
- A conversation that canon summarizes in one line. Write the whole thing.
- The recovery that happened off-page. Who stayed in the room?
- The moment one character found out a secret that canon reveals later.
- What a character did in the hour before their big entrance.
2. After the ending
Every ending leaves questions. What do these people do when there is no more plot? Post-canon stories (sometimes called epilogue fic) work because readers want to stay with the characters a little longer.
Prompts:
- One year later, the first anniversary of the final battle. Who marks it, and how?
- The most competent character is now bored. What do they take up?
- Two characters who never spoke in canon are stuck working together after it.
- Someone finally takes the vacation they kept postponing.
- A character who lost everything in canon is building something new. What is the first thing they make?
- A letter written after the ending, to someone who didn't make it.
3. One changed moment (canon divergence)
Find a turning point in canon (a decision, a near-miss in timing, a secret kept) and make it go the other way. Fans call this canon divergence. You keep the original world and follow the consequences, which gives you a plot for free.
Prompts:
- They said yes instead of no.
- They arrived five minutes earlier.
- The secret came out three chapters sooner.
- The person who left stayed, and the one who stayed left.
- The rescue failed and someone else had to finish the mission.
- The two rivals were assigned as partners from day one.
4. A new setting
Take the characters out of canon entirely and drop them into a coffee shop, a royal court or a space station. This is an AU (alternate universe). The rule is to change the world and keep the people: what they want, what they fear, how they talk and how they treat each other.
There is a full list of 60 AU ideas with a question for each one. A few to start with:
- Coffee shop AU: what does the regular customer order that gives too much away?
- Royalty AU: what does the crown cost each of them?
- College AU: same class, very different reasons for taking it.
- Space station AU: a small crew, one broken system, and someone who knows why it broke.
5. A side character's view
Canon is told from somewhere. Move the camera. A side character, or an uninvolved bystander, sees the main cast from the outside and notices what the protagonists can't. Fans call the bystander version Outsider POV (tagged "POV Outsider" on AO3).
Prompts:
- The shopkeeper who has served the main cast every week for a year.
- A younger sibling watching the older one change over the series.
- The villain's second-in-command on the night before the final battle.
- A classmate or coworker who figured out the big secret and kept quiet.
- The person who had to clean up after the dramatic scene.
- Someone who met a main character before canon started.
6. A trope applied to your pairing
Tropes are story shapes readers love to see again with different characters. The idea is never the trope alone. It is the trope plus the two specific people, and the question of how they would handle it.
Prompts:
- Enemies to lovers: what is the first thing one of them does that the other can't hate?
- Fake dating: who suggested it, and who starts forgetting it's fake?
- Forced proximity: one room, one storm, one bed or one broken elevator.
- Hurt/comfort: who is bad at being taken care of?
- Domestic: the first holiday they spend together on purpose.
- Slow burn: the small thing one of them notices every day for a year.
- Mutual pining: both are sure the other isn't interested. Who finds out first?
- Secret relationship: someone almost catches them.
- Rivals to lovers: they compete over something small and take it far too seriously.
- Amnesia: one forgets, the other has to decide what to tell them.
- Pen pals / epistolary: they can only talk in writing. What do they write that they would never say?
From idea to first scene
An idea becomes a story when you can answer three questions:
- Whose scene is it? Pick the character with the most to lose in this moment.
- What do they want right now? Something small and concrete: to leave the room, to get an answer, to hide a wound.
- What is in the way? Another character, the setting, or their own fear.
If you can answer all three, you can write the opening. If one is missing, the idea is still a premise, and you need to look at it a little longer.
Keep them in character
Readers forgive almost anything in fanfic except characters who stop sounding like themselves. Before you write, note for each character what they want most, what they are afraid of, how they talk, and how they treat the other person. While you write, check each big moment against those notes. A character can change over a story, but the reader should see why.
If you track a lot of these details, keep canon facts and your own additions apart. The fanfic setting sheet has one layer for canon and one for your headcanons, and managing canon in fan work explains the method.
A worked example
Two original characters: Odile, an apprentice lighthouse keeper who talks a lot until it gets dark, and Tamsin, a cartographer who hates being looked after.
- Source: one changed moment. In their story, Tamsin leaves the coast at the end of summer. What if she stays?
- Whose scene: Tamsin's. She has the most to lose by admitting she stayed on purpose.
- What she wants: to explain her staying as practical (the coastline map isn't finished).
- What's in the way: Odile, who has already noticed that the map was finished weeks ago.
First line: "The north soundings still need checking," Tamsin said, and kept her eyes on the chart, because if she looked up, Odile would ask why she was still here.
Find ideas for your characters
Small details about a character often lead to a whole story: what they do on a quiet night, what they would never admit, how they act after a fight. The headcanon generator gives you three headcanon ideas for any character or pairing, each with three scene prompts to start from. Choose a situation such as After a fight or AU / what if to aim it at one of the sources above. It works for canon characters and original characters, and you can try it with a free account.
If the problem is less about ideas and more about getting started at all, see ways through writer's block.
